Skip to main content
The Abbey on Butler Street logo top - HomepageThe Abbey on Butler Street logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
  • About
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • Explore
    • Vesper Room
    • Parlour Bar
    • Coffeehouse
    • Arcade
  • Facebook page
  • Google page

Our Menu

  • Weekly Features
  • Lunch Menu
  • Dinner Menu
  • Sunday Brunch
  • Desserts
  • Arcade Menu

Brunch

Steak and Eggs

$20.00
6oz Strip Steak / Two Eggs Any Style / House-Made Chimichurri / Home Fries

Available 11am-3pm Monday-Saturday

Small Plates

Curry Frites

$12.00
Crispy Fries / Yellow Curry / White Cheddar / Scallions | Add Sunny Egg* 3 / Bacon 4

Edamame Hummus

$13.00/+
Blended Edamame & Olive Oil Spread Served with Grilled Naan | Substitute Fresh Vegetables 2 / Extra Naan 4

Brussels Sprouts

$15.00
Crispy Fried Brussels Sprouts / Hand-Cut Bacon / Cherry Tomato / Sea Salt & Black Pepper / Balsamic Reduction / Crumbled Goat Cheese

Baked Crab Dip

$17.00
Lump Crab / Cream Cheese & Cheddar / Roasted Red Peppers / Grilled Naan

Bistro Mussels & Frites

$20.00
Steamed Mussels / Chardonnay Herbed Tomato Broth / House-Baked Focaccia

Calamari

$18.00
Buttermilk Marinated Calamari / Remoulade / Lemon

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

Salads

House Greens

$15.00
Mixed Greens / Red Onion / Cherry Tomato / Cucumber / Radish / House-Made Croutons / White Balsamic Vinaigrette | Add Chicken 7 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Salmon* 12 / Shrimp 12

Caesar Salad

$17.00
Crisp Romaine Wedges / Aged Shaved Parmesan / House-Made Croutons / Cracked Black Pepper / House Caesar Dressing | Add Chicken 7 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Salmon* 12 / Shrimp 12

Autumn Harvest Salad

$17.00
Spring Greens / Red & Green Apples / Strawberries / Walnuts / Red Onion / Goat Cheese / White Balsamic Vinaigrette | Add Chicken 7 / Salmon* 12 / Shrimp 12

*Salmon is cooked to order. Consuming or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness

Sandwiches

*Gluten free buns available.

Butler Hot Chicken Sandwich

$17.00
Fried Boneless Buttermilk Chicken Breast / Spicy Bacon Fat Sauce / Pickles / Mayo / House-Made Challah Bun | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Abbey’s Classic Tuna Melt

$15.00
Grandma's House-Made Tuna Salad / American Cheese / Tomato / House-Made Rye | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Breakfast Burrito

$15.00
Scrambled Eggs / Hash Browns / Bacon / Cooper American / Flour Tortilla / Salsa | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Steak Sandwich

$17.00
Shaved Jubilee Hilltop Ranch Ribeye / Cooper American / Onions / Roasted Red Peppers / Arugula / Garlic Aioli / House-Made French Roll | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Edamame Wrap (V)

$14.00
Edamame Hummus / Red Onion / Cucumber / Mixed Greens / Tomato / Goat Cheese / Naan | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8 / Chicken 7 / Shrimp 12

Abbey Classic Cheeseburger

$18.00
8oz Locally Sourced Ground Beef* / House-Cured Brown Sugar Peppered Bacon / Cooper White American / Garlic Aioli / Tomato / Romaine / House-Made Challah | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Turkey Romo Melt

$15.00
Shaved Roasted Turkey Breast / Smoked Gouda / Bacon / Apricot Jam / Red Onion / Toasted House-Made Sourdough | Add Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Black Bean Burger

$17.00
House-Made Black Bean Burger / Pickled Red Cabbage Slaw / Red Pepper Aioli / House-Baked Challah Bun | Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

*Burgers cooked to order. Consuming raw or under cooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Entrees

Steak Frites

$19.00
6oz Strip Steak / House-Made Chimichurri / Smoked Paprika & Garlic Fries / Horseradish Cream

Baked Mac & Cheese (V)

$18.00
Campanelli Pasta / Dutch Gouda & White Cheddar / Blistered Tomatoes | Add Bacon 4 / Chicken 7 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Shrimp 12

Fish & Chips

$23.00
Craft Beer Battered Euclid Fish Company Cod / Crispy Fries / Truffled Tartar Sauce / Truffled Ketchup / Grilled Lemon

Asiago Gnocchi (vegetarian)

$25.00
Fire Roasted Corn / Arugula / Basil / Cherry Tomato / Whipped Feta | Add Bacon 4 / Chicken 7 / Shrimp 12

Small Plates

Curry Frites

$12.00
Crispy Fries / Yellow Curry / White Cheddar / Scallions | Add Sunny Egg* 3 / Bacon 4 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Grilled Chicken 7

Bistro Mussels & Frites

$20.00
Steamed Mussels / Chardonnay Herbed Tomato Broth / House-Baked Baguette

Calamari

$18.00
Buttermilk-Marinated Calamari / Remoulade / Grilled Lemon

Baked Crab Dip

$18.00
Lump Crab / Roasted Red Pepper / Cream Cheese & Cheddar / Grilled Naan

House Country Sourdough

$12.00
House-Baked Sourdough served with Smoked Turmeric Butter & Olive Tapenade

Brussels Sprouts

$15.00
Crispy Fried Brussels Sprouts / Hand-cut Bacon / Cherry Tomato / Sea Salt & Cracked Black Pepper / Balsamic Reduction / Goat Cheese

Edamame Hummus

$13.00
Blended Edamame & Olive Oil Spread Served with Grilled Naan | Substitute Fresh Vegetables 2 / Extra Naan 4

* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase risk of foodborne illness

Salads

House Green

$15.00
Mixed greens / Red Onion / Cherry Tomato / Cucumber / Radish / House-Made Croutons / White Balsamic Vinaigrette | Add Chicken 7 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Shrimp 12 / Edamame Falafel (gf) 5 / Salmon 12

Caesar Salad

$17.00
Crisp Romaine / Aged Shaved Parmesan / House-Made Croutons / Cracked Black Pepper / House Caesar Dressing | Add Chicken 7 / Add Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Shrimp 12 / Salmon 12 / Edamame Falafel (gf) 5

Seared Tuna Nicoise Salad

$28.00
Seared Tuna* / Mixed Greens / Mixed Olives / Heirloom Tomato / Roasted Potato / Hard Boiled Egg / Red Onion / White Balsamic Vinaigrette

Side House Salad

$5.00
Mixed Greens / Red Onion / Cherry Tomato / Cucumber / Radish / House-Made Croutons / White Balsamic Vinaigrette

Side Caesar

$6.00
Crisp Romaine / Aged Shaved Parmesan / House-Made Croutons / Cracked Black Pepper / House Caesar Dressing

*

Salmon cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Entrees

Red Curry Shrimp & Grits

$28.00
Grilled Shrimp / Cheddar Grits / Coconut-Corn Relish / Red Curry Butter

Bavette Steak

$48.00
10oz Sliced Bavette Steak* / Horseradish Mashed Potatoes / Rapini / Rum Demi Glace | Add Shrimp 12 / Mushrooms 5 / Blue Cheese 3

Baked Mac & Cheese (v)

$18.00
Campanelli Pasta / Dutch Gouda & White Cheddar / Oven Blistered Tomatoes | Add Bacon 4 / Chicken 7 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Shrimp 12

Herbed Chicken

$28.00
10oz Airline Chicken Breast / Sweet Corn Puree / Blistered Green Beans & Tomato / Mirepoix Jus

Bone-In Pork Loin

$36.00
10oz Bone-in Pork Loin / Braised Brussels Sprouts / Pancetta / Mushroom & Onion Gravy / Barley Risotto

Seared Tuna Nicoise Salad

$28.00
Seared Tuna* / Field Greens / Mixed Olives / Cornichons / Cherry Tomato / Roasted Potatoes / Hard Boiled Egg / Red Onion / White Balsamic Vinaigrette

Asiago Gnocchi (v)

$25.00
Fire Roasted Corn / Arugula / Basil / Cherry Tomato / Whipped Feta | Add Chicken 7 / Bacon 4

Laurel Hill Trout

$32.00
10oz Trout Filet / Roasted Carrot & Ginger Purée / Oven Roasted Potatoes

Fish & Chips

$27.00
10oz Beer Battered Cod / Crispy Fries / Truffled Tartar Sauce / Truffled Ketchup / Grilled Lemon

Abbey Classic Cheeseburger

$18.00
8oz Locally Sourced Ground Beef* / House-Cured Bacon / Sharp American / Garlic Aioli / Tomato / Romaine / House-Baked Challah Bun | Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Black Bean Burger

$17.00
House-Made Black Bean Burger / Pickled Slaw / Red Pepper Aioli / House-Baked Challah Bun | Pasta Salad / Fries 2 / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Edamame Falafel (gf & vegan)

$18.00
House-Made Edamame Falafel with Summer Succotash / Smoked Tomato Coulis / Almond Cashew Puree

*Steaks are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Starters & Salads

Curry Frites

$12.00
Crispy Fries/ House Yellow Curry/ White Cheddar/ Scallions 12 +Add Sunny Egg* +3/ Bacon +4

Edamame Hummus

$13.00/+
Blended Edamame & Olive Oil Spread 13 / Served with Seasoned Naan / Served with Fresh Vegetables 15 / Extra Side of Naan 4

Blueberry Parfait

$8.00
Greek Yogurt / Blueberry Compote / Mixed Nut Granola / Honey Drizzle

House Greens

$14.00
Mixed Greens/ Red Onion/ Cherry Tomatoes/ Cucumbers/ Radish/ House Made Croutons/ White Balsamic Vinaigrette / +Add Chicken +7

Caesar Salad

$16.00
Crisp Romaine Wedges / Aged Shaved Parmesan/ House Made Croutons / Cracked Black Pepper / House Caesar Dressing / Add Chicken +7/ Shrimp +12

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness.

Eggs

The Abbey Breakfast

$17.00
The Abbey Breakfast Two Eggs Cooked to Order*/ Choice of Sugar-Cured Bacon, Veggie Sausage, or Sausage Links/ Home Fries/ Choice of Toast

Country Fried Sirloin & Eggs

$20.00
Country Fried Sirloin & Eggs Thinly Pounded Country Fried Sirloin/ Country Cream Gravy/ Two Eggs Cooked to Order*/ Home Fries/ Scallions

Steak & Egg Hash

$20.00
Sliced Jubilee Hilltop Ribeye/ Home Fries/ Caramelized Onions/ Roasted Cherry Tomatoes/ White Cheddar/ Bourbon St. BBQ/ Two Eggs Sunny-Side*/ Everything Bagel Seasoning/ Scallions

Vegetable Omelet

$17.00
Three Eggs/ Red Onion/ Roasted Red Pepper/ Roasted Cherry Tomatoes/ Spinach / White Cheddar/ Home Fries / Add Bacon / Sausage / Vegetarian Sausage +5

Frittata

$19.00
Three Eggs/ Chopped Bacon/ Sliced Sausage/ Spinach / Caramelized Onion / Roasted Red Pepper / Cherry Tomatoes/ Potato/ Cheddar

*Consuming raw o undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness

Steak And Eggs

$20.00
6oz Strip Steak / Two Eggs Any Style / House-Made Chimichurri / Home Fries

Comforts

Sourdough French Toast

$14.00
Sourdough French Toast Thick Sliced Sourdough/ Caramelized Peaches/ Granola/ Maple Syrup/ Powdered Sugar

Rose Window Pancakes

$15.00
Fluffy Vegan Pancakes/ Maple Blueberry Syrup / Nut Butter/ Powdered Sugar

Classic Waffle

$13.00
Thick Belgian Waffle/ Strawberry Compote/ Whipped Mascarpone / Maple Syrup / Powdered Sugar

Sandwiches

Late Breakfast Burger

$19.00
Late Breakfast Burger Coffee Rubbed 8oz Burger/ Sugar-Cured Bacon/ Sweet Caramelized Onions// Hash Brown / Aged Cheddar/ Sriracha Maple Ketchup/ French Toasted Challah / Pasta Salad/ Fries +2 / Greens +3 / Home Fries +2

Chicken Avacado

$17.00
Grilled Chicken / Bacon / Smoked Gouda / Garlic Aioli / Mixed Greens / Tomato/ Naan / Pasta Salad/ Fries +2 / Greens +3 / Home Fries +2

Rachel

$15.00
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast/ Purple Cabbage Slaw/ Swiss Cheese/ 1K Sauce/ Griddled Marble Rye / Pasta Salad/ Fries +2 / Greens +3 / Home Fries +2

BE&C

$17.00
Sugar-Cured Thick Sliced Bacon/ Two Over Hard Eggs/ Thick American Cheese/ Grilled Sourdough / Pasta Salad/ Fries +2 / Greens +3 / Home Fries +2

Entrees

Shrimp & Grits

$26.00
Stone Ground Corn Cheesy Southern Grits/ Shrimp/ Tomato Basil/ Roasted Red Peppers/ Tabasco/ Egg Yolk/ Scallions

Chicken & Waffles

$20.00
Crispy Fried Chicken Breast/ Buttermilk Waffle/ Spicy Citrus Honey Butter/ Pure New York Maple Syrup/ Powdered Sugar

Smothered Chicken Biscuit

$20.00
House made Biscuit/ Fried Chicken Breast/ Cheddar/ Sugar-Cured Bacon/ Country Cream Gravy/ Home Fries

Curry Tofu Scramble

$16.00
Crumbled Tofu/ House Yellow Curry Sauce/ Red Onion/ Kale/ Tomato/ Home Fries / Add Bacon / Sausage / Vegetarian Sausage +5

Sides

Veggie Sausage Patties (3)

$5.00

Bacon (5)

$5.00

Breakfast Sausage Links (3)

$5.00

Hash Browns

$5.00

Home Fries

$5.00

Cheesy Grits

$5.00

Plant Chicken

$9.00

Desserts

Belgian Chocolate Mousse Cake

$12.00
Rich Belgian Chocolate Cake / Raspberry Coulis / Chocolate Crumble

New York Style Cheesecake

$10.00
Classic, Ultra Creamy Cheesecake on a Graham Cracker Crust/ Strawberry Compote / Cookie Crumble

Apricot Jam Oat Bar

$7.00
Vegan Gluten Free / Apricot Jam / Dense And Filling

Arcade Food

Edamame Hummus

$15.00
Blended Edamame & Olive Oil Spread Served with Grilled Naan | Substitute Fresh Vegetables 15 / Additional Naan 4

Crab Dip

$17.00
Lump Crab / Roasted Red Pepper / Cream Cheese & Cheddar / Grilled Pita

Curry Fries

$12.00
Crispy Fries / Yellow Curry / White Cheddar / Scallions / Add Sunny Egg* 3 / Bacon 4 / Butler Hot Chicken 9 / Grilled Chicken 7

Caesar Salad

$17.00
Crisp Romaine / Aged Shaved Parmesan / House-Made Croutons / Cracked Black Pepper / House Caesar Dressing | Add Chicken 7 / Shrimp 12 / Edamame Falafel (gf) 5

House Salad

$15.00
Mixed Greens / Red Onion / Cherry Tomato / Cucumber / Radish / House-Made Croutons / White Balsamic Vinaigrette | Add Chicken 7 / Shrimp 12 / Edamame Falafel (gf) 5

Abbey Classic Cheeseburger

$18.00
8oz Locally Sourced Ground Beef* / House-Cured Bacon / Sharp White American / Garlic Aioli / Tomato / Romaine / House-Baked Challah Bun | Pasta Salad / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Black Bean Burger

$17.00
House-Made Black Bean Burger / Pickled Slaw / Red Pepper Aioli / House-Baked Challah Bun | Pasta Salad / Greens 3 / Baked Mac & Cheese 8

Fish & Chips

$25.00
10oz Beer Battered Cod / Crispy Fries / Truffled Tartar Sauce / Truffled Ketchup / Grilled Lemon

Arcade Cocktails

Bourbon Slush

$13.00
Maker's Mark Bourbon / Orange Juice / Red Soda

Apple Cider Slush

$13.00
Spiced Rum / Apple Cider / Spiced Simple / Orange Juice

Arcade Margarita

$12.00
Tequila Blanco / Orange Liqueur / Fresh Citrus

Espresso Martini

Espresso Infused Tito's / Coffee Liqueur / Drip Coffee

Bottles & Cans

Duquesne Pilsner

White Claw

Corona

PBR Pounders

PBR Light Pounders

Troegs Dreamweaver

Tecate

Draft Beer

Von Trapp Oktoberfest

5.6%

Bravazzi Blood Orange Hard Italian Soda (Served Over Ice)

4.2%

Lancaster Milk Stout

5.3%

North Country Northern Light Lager

4.1%

New Belgium Voodoo Ranger Juice Force Hazy Imperial IPA

$8.00
9.5%

Allagash White

5.2%

IC Light Lager

4.13%

Labatt Blue Canadian Lager

5%

Stella Artois Belgian Lager

5.2%

Guiness Stout (Nitro)

4.2%

3 Floyds Gumballhead Wheat Pale Ale

$7.00
5.6%

Helltown Buffy Hazy IPA

$8.00
6.7%

Urban Artifact Capy Snacks Fruit Ale

$8.00
5%

Troegs Leaf Seeker IPA

$7.00
6.5%

Arsenal Cider Grant's Flying Pumpkin (8 oz)

$8.00
8.4%

Cigar City Brewing Maduro Brown Ale

$7.00
5.5 %

Cigar City Maduro Brown Ale

$7.00
5.5%

Rhinegeist Truth IPA

$7.00
7.2%

Dales Pale Ale

$7.00
6.5%

North Coast Old Rasputin Imperial Stout

$9.00
9.0%
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs